[horde] Doubt about default shares creation

[Jan Schneider]

Zitat von "Michael J.Rubinsky" <mrubinsk at horde.org>:

>
> Quoting Jan Schneider <jan at horde.org>:
>
>> Zitat von Alfonso Marín Marín <almarin at um.es>:
>>
>>> Hi list:
>>>
>>> I have a doubt. The first time that an users log in, Kronolith (  
>>> and others shared enabled application) checks if already exists  
>>> any visible share for that user, and if so, it doesn't create the  
>>> personal one. ¿What is the point to do that?
>>>
>>> With this behaviour, if an user A gives show permissions to user B  
>>> before user B log in the first time, user B won't have any  
>>> personal share.
>>>
>>> Maybe it would be nice have a config option to indicate that a  
>>> personal share must be created regardless of the displayable ones.
>>
>> Sounds about right, though this shouldn't be configurable.
>
> This was done this way on purpose. We don't want the user's personal  
> share to automatically be created for a number of reasons. First,  
> for apps like Turba, it's possible to have multiple backend data  
> stores. We don't want to have each one of those having a personal  
> share created on it automatically. It's also possible the user is  
> using an app such as kronolith only to access a remote calendar, for  
> instance and the user does not want another, local calendar created.  
> There were a number of complaints about this prior to adding this  
> feature.
>
> The way it works, at least in Turba, is if there is any address book  
> the user has Perms::WRITE access to, then we don't create another  
> one. I can check that this is the case for the other share apps as  
> well, but I believe we should still prevent the creation of the  
> "default" share if there as at least one other source with write  
> permissions for the current user.

I don't agree. I think it's more confusing to the user if he doesn't  
get a personal share for some reason that really escapes him. I see  
that there might be a reason where we don't want to create a share,  
but this should be really limited, well-defined situations, e.g. for  
guest users obviously.

Jan.

-- 
Do you need professional PHP or Horde consulting?
http://horde.org/consulting/