[dev] [commits] Horde-Hatchery branch master updated. d3fcd5cdd11ada51d44c03fccd529ba9beed543d

[Jan Schneider]

Zitat von Chuck Hagenbuch <chuck at horde.org>:

> Quoting Jan Schneider <jan at horde.org>:
>
>>> Most important, both the horde core and framework need to live in  
>>> the same repo.  When fixing bugs in an application, often the fix  
>>> is actually in a framework lib, or a horde core component, or a  
>>> combo of all three locations.  This commit message should be a  
>>> single standalone item so we can point to a single commit message  
>>> as solving a single bug report.
>>
>> That's a good point, and it's actually also a reason to not have a  
>> separate hatchery at all. If we only had one single repository for  
>> all application and framework code, we don't have any problems with  
>> commits spanning two repositories. And there shouldn't be a problem  
>> with merging hatchery to horde-git either.
>> Did I really say that? :) I still would prefer having one repo per  
>> application, but I'm giving in that this really isn't feasible with  
>> Git atm.
>
> I am leaning heavily towards a single repository also, based on both  
> our experience and also on my experience with git at work. We can  
> use branches much more than we currently do to keep things that  
> aren't ready for production out of the main view, for refactoring,  
> etc.
>
>> I see the main reasons for having all horde apps under the horde/  
>> directory being the groupware bundles and maintainability. We can't  
>> provide groupware tarballs that extract to multiple directories and  
>> files in the current directory, so we need a common parent  
>> directory anyway.
>
> Couldn't that common parent directory be named "groupware", and  
> contain both a horde/ directory along with directories for all of  
> the included apps?

That should work, with the current style of packaging anyway. I'm not  
sure yet how to create the bundles when the applications are  
pear-installable but time will tell.

Jan.

-- 
Do you need professional PHP or Horde consulting?
http://horde.org/consulting/