[ingo] from issue, procmail issue

Jason Keltz jas at cse.yorku.ca
Fri Oct 17 15:12:41 UTC 2008


I'm moving a whole bunch of our users onto Ingo, so I guess that I'm 
bound to run into a few issues.

One issue is that users who are used to filtering based on "From" (and 
not From:") in procmail are trying to filter using the "From:" header as 
if it were "From".  I guess it's not an INGO "problem" per se.  For 
example, they use rules like "From:" starts with "user at domain.com".  The 
problem, of course, is that From: first contains a full name like this:

From: John Smith <user at domain.com>

... so it doesn't match.  I tried adding a "custom" header based on just 
"From" since the messages have a header "From user at domain.com", but that 
didn't work.  I know they can use regular expressions, of course, but I 
wonder why the "From" header without the ":" isn't listed in the list of 
possible headers.  This way, users could use the easier filter rule 
rather than always using a regular expression.  I tried adding "From" as 
another header, but INGO automatically adds a ":" after it.

Secondly, one of our staff created a whole bunch of rules to save 
messages from individuals into folders, and also to keep a copy in her 
inbox using Ingo's "save a copy in my inbox and redirect to" type rule. 
  She did this with her own mail as well creating a rule that looks like 
this (since procmail is our backend):

##### me #####
:0
* ^From: me
{
   :0 c
   ! me

   :0
   $DEFAULT
}

Procmail goes into a loop and delivers 13 copies of the message to 
herself.  I'm not certain that I understand it  I guess this is because 
procmail is somehow reprocessing the message after it has been delivered 
to her inbox?  I'd just like to understand whether this is a bug or a 
feature.  I can imagine that users might like to save a copy of their 
own messages in their inbox (even though it's already in their sent mail 
folder).

Thanks in advance for any feedback.

Jason.



More information about the ingo mailing list